|
Author
|
Topic
|
Date of posting
|
|
Christian Fiala
- Jorge Perez
- Christian Fiala
|
HIV test
|
17 May 2000
19 May 2000
21 May 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
- Jorge Perez
- David Rasnick
|
What's next?
|
18 May 2000
20 May 2000
21 May 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
The Sexual Transmission of AIDS ?
|
23 May 2000
|
|
Moderators
- David Rasnick
- Roberto Giraldo
- Perth Group
- David Rasnick
- Perth Group
- Christian Fiala
|
Launch of the Internet debate
|
23 May 2000
24 May 2000
|
|
Perth Group
- Roberto Giraldo
- Harvey Bialy
|
The oxidative stress theory and HIV/AIDS
|
24 May 2000
25 May 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Dissidents in the main stream
|
24 May 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Our posting truncated problem with the website
Remainder of oxidative stress
HIV Transmission (parts III and IV)
|
25 May 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
'Room C' discussion?
|
25 May 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
Some questions for Drs Gallo, Montagnier & Makgoba
|
26 May
|
|
Perth Group
|
Comments on suggested experiments
|
26 May 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
Cofactors: HIV/AIDS Debate
|
26 May 2000
|
|
Peter Duesberg
- David Rasnick
- Ray Mabope
- Roberto Giraldo
|
Next panel meeting
|
27 May 2000
30 May 2000
31 May 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
The origin of the 'transmission' of AIDS
|
27 May 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
- Roberto Giraldo
- Perth Group
- Ray Mabope
|
Topics deleted
|
27 May 2000
28 May 2000
30 May 2000
|
|
Robert Giraldo
|
Tests for HIV are highly inaccurate
|
28 May 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
Questions for Drs Gallo, Montagnier & Kakgoba
|
28 May 2000
|
|
Robert Giraldo
|
Questions for the moderators
|
29 May 2000
|
|
Robert Giraldo
|
'Cofactors' cause AIDS
|
29 May 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Defenders of HIV, where are you?
|
30 May 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Thanks to moderators
|
31 May 2000
|
|
ML Kothari
|
Issues for the next HIV meeting
|
31 May 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
A request of South African epidemiologists
|
31 May 2000
|
|
Moderators
- Harvey Bialy
- David Rasnick
|
Moderators perspective
|
1 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
Protease Inhibitors and magical cures
|
2 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
Circumcision and AIDS in Africa
|
2 June 2000
10 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
- Harvey Bialy
- Roberto Giraldo
- Harvey Bialy
- Roberto Giraldo
|
Animal models of AIDS
|
3 June 2000
7 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Overwhelming evidence
|
3 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
More on protease inhibitors / AIDS docs take note
|
4 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
1992 AIDS peaked in USA
|
4 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Decline in AIDS deaths
|
4 June 2000
|
|
Moderators
- Joseph Sonnabend
- Harvey Bialy
- David Rasnick
- Roberto Giraldo
|
Moderators perspective
|
5 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
The overwhelming evidence is presented here
|
5 June 2000
6 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Break the silence
|
5 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
New folks, Welcome!
|
6 June 2000
|
|
ML Kothari
|
Dr Rasnick's call to break the silence
A measure of success?
|
6 June 2000
9 June 2000
10 June 2000
|
|
Helpdesk
- David Rasnick
- Gordon Stewart
- Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
- Helpdesk
- Roberto Giraldo
|
Website problems that are experienced by the panel
How do we send graphic files?
Website problems that are experienced by the panel
|
6 June 2000
14 June 2000
7 June 2000
|
|
C Koehnlein
- Joseph Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- Harvey
|
Re: J Sonnabend
|
6 June 2000
7 June 2000
8 June 2000
|
|
Robert Giraldo
|
Breastfeeding and AIDS in Africa
|
7 June 2000
9 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Agenda for proposed July meeting
|
7 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
- Charles Geshekter
- Zena Stein
|
TB versus AIDS in South Africa
|
7 June 2000
9June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Anti-HIV drugs fail in children
|
7 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Malaria versus AIDS
|
7 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
Perth-Group versus William Makgoba HIV/AIDS debate
|
7 June 2000
8 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
AIDS among US ethnic Minorities
|
8 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
- Harvey Bialy
- David Rasnick
|
First comments on revised NIH document
|
8 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Pregnant monkeys exposed to AZT
|
8 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
HIV protease inhibitors and diabetes
|
8 June 2000
|
|
Alan Whiteside
- Roberto Giraldo
- Harvey Bialy
- David Rasnick
- Christian Fiala
- Harvey Bialy
- Charles Geshekter
|
Increased mortality
Increased mortality due to what?
Increased mortality
|
8 June 2000
9 June 2000
11 June 2000
12 June 2000
|
|
Moderators
- Joseph Sonnabend
- Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
- David Rasnick
- Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
- Jorge Perez
- Peter Duesberg
- Christian Fiala
- David Rasnick
- Helene Gayle
- David Rasnick
- Helene Gayle
|
Moderators perspective
An apology
Moderators perspective
Where are the data from SA?
Firmly established strategy
Moderators perspective
Should we worry?
Moderators perspective
|
9 June 2000
11 June 2000
9 June 2000
16 June 2000
19 June 2000
10 June 2000
13 June 2000
14 June 2000
13 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
Perth Group vs William Makgoba
|
9 June 2000
11 June 2000
|
|
Joseph Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- Harvey Bialy
- Alan Whiteside
- Harvey Bialy
|
Associated infections, poverty and HIV
|
9 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
- Roberto Giraldo
- Harvey Bialy
|
EUREKA
|
9 June 2000
10 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
Six questions refried & reposted
|
9 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
The causes of AIDS
|
9 June 2000
|
|
Carolyn Williamson
- David Rasnick
- Carolyn Williamson
- Harvey Bialy
- David Rasnick
- Harvey Bialy
|
The virus
|
9 June 2000
10 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
The overwhelming evidence against, or 'a rose by any other name'
|
10 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
Question to moderators
|
10 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
HIV innocent of crime of AIDS
|
10 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Exhibit B for the defense
|
10 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Exhibit C for the defense
|
|
|
ML Kothari
|
Alleged moderation of the debate
|
10 June 2000
11 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Exhibit D for the defense
|
11 June 2000
13 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Witnesses for the defense
|
11 June 2000
|
|
Joseph Sonnabend
- Joseph Sonnabend
- Peter Duesberg
- Joseph Sonnabend
- Charles Geshekter
- Harvey Bialy
- Peter Duesberg
- Joseph Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- Joseph Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- J Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- J Sonn…
- D Rasnick
- Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
- Joseph Sonnabend
|
Heterosexual transmission: Differences in Africa
Your first question
Heterosexual transmission: Differences in Africa
An honourable contribution
Progress
Prescribed drugs
Your 1st question
Progress
An honourable contribution
|
11 June 2000
12 June 2000
13 June 2000
15 June 2000
16 June 2000
12 June 2000
13 June 2000
14 June 2000
13 June 2000
16 June 2000
12 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
The natural history of AIDS
|
12 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
- Ray Mabope
- Charles Geshekter
- Helpdesk
|
Moderators: Where are you?
|
12 June 2000
14 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Witness for the defense
|
12 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Questioning the HIV/AIDS theory
To the majority
|
12 June 2000
|
|
ML Kothari
|
HIV causes AIDS (!)
|
12 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Textbook on HIV/AIDS
|
12 June 2000
13 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
- Etienne de Harven
- Roberto Giraldo
|
Witness for the defense
|
13 June 2000
14 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Witness for the defense
Collaboratory testimony
|
13 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
Anti-retrovirals cause AIDS
|
14 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
An explanation for why the majority pretends uninterested
|
14 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
- Ray Mabope (Robert Root-Bernstein)
|
The NIH and Montagnier's virus
|
14 June 2000
15 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Televise the next meeting
|
15 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
The Orwellina Coovadia
|
15 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Root-Bernstein
Good point!
|
15 June 2000
16 June 2000
|
|
Alan Whiteside
- Harvey Bialy
- Roberto Giraldo
- Alan Whiteside
- Charles Geshekter
- Harvey Bialy
- Alan Whiteside
|
Evidence on increased mortality
More on increased mortality
|
15 June 2000
16 June 2000
18 June 2000
25 June 2000
26 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
Some words from the truly wise, with a comment from the merely inquisitive
|
15 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Answering Root-Bernstein
Check task team
|
16 June 2000
|
|
Joseph Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- Joseph Sonnabend
- Peter Duesberg
- Joseph Sonnabend
- C Koehnlein
- Perth Group
|
A physician's perspective
Visit your facility
There you go again
A physician's perspective
|
16 June 2000
17 June 2000
18 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
NIH and 'HIV' antibodies + experiments
|
16 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
An effective treatment of AIDS
|
17 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Witness for the defense
|
17 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Before it's over
|
17 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
|
A reply to Prof Makgoba
Correction
Addendum
|
17 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
Witness for the prosecution
|
17 June 2000
18 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
- The moderators
- Carolyn Williamson
|
Everybody is HIV- positive
|
18 June 2000
23 June 2000
26 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
- Alan Whiteside
- Harvey Bialy
|
A general question
|
18 June 2000
19 June 2000
|
|
Etienne de Harven
|
Answering Root-Bernstein
|
18 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Summary dismissal of the charges
|
18 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Perth group postings
|
19 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
An effective prevention of AIDS
|
19 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
A final few words about the 'data in the public domain'
|
19 June 2000
|
|
Stefano Bertozzi
- David Rasnick
- Harvey Bialy
- C Koehnlein
- Harvey Bialy
|
How to be helpful?
|
19 June 2000
20 June 2000
21 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
NIH and 'HIV' antibodies + experiments
|
19 June 2000
|
|
ML Kothari
|
Suppressio Veri - Suggestio falsi
|
19 June 2000
|
|
Etienne de Harven
|
Statement
|
19 June 2000
|
|
Etienne de Harven
|
Proposal #1
|
19 June 2000
|
|
Etienne de Harven
|
Proposal #2
|
19 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
What does all of this mean for South Africa
|
20 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
- The moderators
- Elephant or mouse
|
Is there a role for consensus in science?
|
20 June 2000
23 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Answer to Bob Root-Bernstein
|
20 June 2000
|
|
Moderators
- Peter Duesberg
- Joseph Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- Roberto Giraldo
- The moderators
|
Some specific questions
|
20 June 2000
21 June 2000
23 June 2000
|
|
ML Kothari
|
All ART is cytotoxic
|
20 June 2000
|
|
Etienne de Harven
|
Proposal #3
|
20 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope
- David Rasnick
- Roberto Giraldo
- Perth Group
|
July meeting
|
20 June 2000
21 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Questions for the moderators
|
21 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
Some possible trials
|
21 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Comments on Joe Sonnabend's posting
Reply
|
21 June 2000
|
|
ML Kothari
|
Waxing/waning on vaccine/ART
|
21 June 2000
|
|
Peter Duesberg
|
Panellists engaged in pogrom of non-HIV-AIDS minorities
|
21 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
- Harvey Bialy
|
A copy of a letter to Helene Gayle and William Makgoba
A reply from Prof Makgoba
A reply from Dr Gayle
Further words from Prof Makgoba
|
21 June 2000
22 June 2000
23 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
The Cold War of AIDS
|
21 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Flights to Johannesburg
|
21 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
A query of Drs Gayle and Bertozzi in light of their signing the Durban declaration
|
22 June 2000
|
|
ML Kothari
- Lynn Morris
- Roberto Giraldo
- Peter Duesberg
- The moderators
- Carolyn Williamson
- D Rasnick
- H Bialy
- C Williamson
- Lynn Morris
- Perth Group
- Etienne de Harven
- J Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- J Sonnabend
- David Rasnick
- Perth Group
- Etienne de Harven
- Roberto Giraldo
|
Bottomline on HIV-AIDS
Response to the moderators
Moder of AIDS
Response to the moderators
Bottomline on HIV-AIDS
Questions to Dr Morris
Bottomline on HIV-AIDS
How big a benefit?
It's your patients I'm asking about
We are getting closer
Bottomline on HIV-AIDS
|
22 June 2000
23 June 2000
25 June 2000
23 June 2000
22 June 2000
23 June 2000
|
|
Peter Duesberg
- Joseph Sonnabend
- Peter Duesberg
|
The African AIDS epidemic: New and contagious or old under a new name?
|
23 June 2000
24 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Response to nature's open letter to President Mbeki
|
23 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
No evidence that HIV originated from African monkies
|
23 June 2000
|
|
Andrew Herxheimer
|
A personal statement and a suggestion
|
23 June 2000
24 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
Finally an answer from William Makgoba from my frequently posted six questions on HIV/AIDS etiology
|
23 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope
- Harvey Bialy
- Joseph Sonnabend
- Ray Mabope
|
Input from Prof Makgoba
Am I missing something
Input from Prof Makgoba
|
23 June 2000
24 June 2000
25 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope
|
Input from Prof Salim Abdool-Karim
|
23 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Moderators as advocates? De-cloak thyself
|
23 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
A particularly telling exchange between Perth & Makgoba
|
24 June 2000
|
|
Moderators
- Harvey Bialy
- Peter Duesberg
|
Correction
|
24 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Prof Salim Abdool-Karim)
- Peter Duesberg
- Ray Mabope (for Prof Salim Abdool-Karim)
- Roberto Giraldo
- Harvey Bialy
- David Rasnick
|
Similarities and differences in the patters of HIV/AIDS epidemics: South Africa compared to Western Europe and the USA
Addendum
Prof Salim Abdool-Karim
|
24 June 2000
25 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Prof Luc Montagnier)
- Harvey Bialy
- David Rasnick
- Ray Mabope
- Peter Duesberg
- David Rasnick
- Ray Mabope
|
Facts, figures and propositions about AIDS
Prof Luc Montagnier
Facts, figures and propositions about AIDS
On behalf of Montagnier
|
24 June 2000
25 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
- Peter Duesberg
- Harvey Bialy
|
One more experiment
|
25 June 2000
26 June 2000
27 June 2000
|
|
Peter Duesberg
|
Drug holidays? Or why even the HIV/AIDS orthodoxy isn't all bad
|
25 June 2000
|
|
Christian Fiala
|
Epidemiological evidence against heterosexual transmission of HIV and against prevention-campaigns
|
26 June 2000
|
|
Etienne de Harven
|
Durban Declaration
|
25 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
Does HIV exist? Reply to Peter Duesberg and the case against.
|
26 June 2000
|
|
Lynn Morris
- Peter Duesberg
- Perth Group
|
Former dissidents take HAART
|
26 June 2000
27 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Drs AD Mbewu, P Onyebujoh, SP Reddy, S Singh and P Matchaba)
|
The South African response to HIV/AIDS
|
26 June 2000
27 June 2000
|
|
Lynn Morris
- Carolyn Williamson
- Alan Whiteside
- David Rasnick
- Peter Duesberg
|
Panel meeting and format and topics
|
26 June 2000
27 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
No proof for simian AIDS
|
26 June 2000
|
|
Etienne de Harven
|
Durban declaration
|
26 June 2000
|
|
Roberto Giraldo
|
Is HIV 69 years old?
|
27 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Helene Gayle)
|
Perinatal prevention
|
27 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Helene Gayle)
|
Blood safety
|
27 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Helene Gayle)
- Carolyn Williamson
- Harvey Bialy
|
Surveillance
UNAIDS stats
|
27 June 2000
28 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Helene Gayle)
|
Prevention of sexual transmission
|
27 June 2000
28 June 2000
|
|
ML Khotari
|
Principles governing HIV debate
|
27 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Helene Gayle)
|
Post exposure prophylaxis
|
27 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
Ray Mabope
|
27 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
- Etienne de Harven
- Harvey Bialy
- Peter Duesberg
|
Preventing HIV in infants
|
27 June 2000
28 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
|
Causal inference
|
27 June 2000
|
|
Lynn Morris
- Peter Duesberg
- Lynn Morris
|
Factors affecting transmission and progression
|
27 June 2000
28 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope
- Etienne de Harven
- Ray Mabope
|
Details of the July meeting
|
27 June 2000
28 June 2000
|
|
Lynn Morris
|
HIV ELISAs
|
27 June 2000
|
|
Harvey Bialy
|
The rash of sudden posts
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Christian Fiala
|
Answer to Prof Salim Abdool-Karim
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Perth Group
|
SIV and SAIDS
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Alan Whiteside
|
The agenda
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope (for Prof W Makgoba)
- Roberto Giraldo
- Peter Duesberg
|
HIV testing
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
Role of media
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
Virginity tests
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
Pre-determined outcome HIV/AIDS debate
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
The shocking truth about protease inhibitors… a visual 'wake-up-call'
|
28 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
CDCs documented deception (and upload of document)
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
The Durban declaration vs the Presidential AIDS Panel
|
28 June 2000
29 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
Cofactors: HIV/AIDS debate
|
28 June 2000
29 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
Jose Zuniga? Private Internet co-owner
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Sam Mhlongo
|
?? Micrograph of the HIV
|
28 June 2000
|
|
David Rasnick
|
One more experiment revisited
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
|
Causal inference
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
|
Preventing HIV in infants
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
|
Agenda
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
|
Preventing mother-to-child transmission
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
|
Preventing HIV in infants - continuation
|
28 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
|
Causal inference
|
28 June 2000
29 June 2000
|
|
Zena Stein
- David Rasnick
- Peter Duesberg
|
Causal inference - continuation
Is this your best evidence?
|
28 June 2000
29 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope
|
Nominations of presenters on the topics
|
29 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope
- Robert Root-Bernstein
- Robert Root-Bernstein
- Ray Mabope
|
Wind down discussions
Final comments
Wind down discussions
|
29 June 2000
30 June 2000
|
|
Ray Mabope
|
Programme for the panel meeting
|
29 June 2000
|
|
Christian Fiala
|
The future of this forum
|
9 July 2000
20 July 2000
|
|
Anthipi Pouris
|
Draft AIDS report for comments
|
31 August 2000
12 September 2000
|