VIRUSMYTH HOMEPAGE


LETTER TO JOHN MADDOX FROM PETER DUESBERG AND HARVEY BIALY


February 7, 1995

Sir John Maddox
Nature, Macmillan Publishing
4 Little Essex St.
London, WC2R 3LF England

Dear John,

As per your invitation, published in News and Views "Duesberg and the new view of HIV," and your invitation to Harvey Bialy over the phone, "to comment on last week's publications" by Wei et al. and Ho et al. we submit "Responding to 'Duesberg and the new view of HIV'" by Duesberg & Bialy. We are delighted that after years of editorials, News & Views, and letters and censored letters we have been invited at last to make our case in our own words.

As you can see, our report meets your criteria of "not libellous or needlessly rude, that it pertains to the new results and that it should not be longer than it needs to be." The length of our commentary is compatible with the results presented in the two papers covering 10 pages, and the challenges delivered by the two accompanying News & Views from you and Wain-Hobson.

We both respect your courage and integrity to undertake an uncensored debate on the HIV-AIDS hypothesis.

Best regards

Peter Duesberg

Harvey Bialy


P.S. A hard copy is in the mail. We can send a disc if that helps.


VIRUSMYTH HOMEPAGE