LETTER FUELS SOUTH AFRICA'S AIDS FURORE
By Michael Cherry
Nature 27 April 2000
Cape Town -- International controversy over the South African president Thabo Mbeki's
views on the nature of AIDS deepened last week, when the text of an
outspoken letter sent earlier this month to US President Bill Clinton,
UN secretary-general Kofi Annan and the heads of state of Germany,
France and the United Kingdom became public.
In the letter, Mbeki gives the strongest evidence yet of his sympathies
for those who argue that AIDS may not be caused by HIV.
Ironically, earlier in the week James Wolfensohn, president of the World
Bank, had promised that there would be "no limit" to the funds available
for combating AIDS in the developing world. In his statement, delivered
during the annual World Bank meeting in Washington, Wolfensohn singled
out sub-Saharan Africa as being in particular need.
The publication of the letter coincided with the release of South
Africa's AIDS statistics for 1999, which confirm that nearly ten per
cent of its population — about 4.2 million people — is infected with
Mbeki's letter was passed to The Washington Post by a senior US
official, following a meeting in Atlanta the previous week between South
Africa's health minister Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, its ambassador to the
United States, Makate Sisulu, and Sandra Thurman, director of the White
House office of national AIDS policy.
In the letter, Mbeki states that he is "convinced that our urgent task
is to respond to the specific threat that faces us as Africans. We will
not eschew this obligation in favour of the comfort of the recitation of
a catechism that may very well be a correct response to the specific
manifestation of AIDS in the West."
Referring to 'dissident' AIDS researchers who believe that HIV does not
cause AIDS, he continues: "The scientists we are supposed to put into
scientific quarantine include Nobel prizewinners, members of academies
of science and emeritus professors of various disciplines of medicine!"
In the South African parliament last Wednesday, Jacob Zuma, deputy
president and chairman of the National AIDS Council, denied that Mbeki
had at any stage said that he challenges the view that HIV causes
AIDS — or the contrary.
"During the last decade and a half and more, a heated debate amongst
scientists and others relating to this question, has been going on,"
said Zuma. Rallying to the president's position, he continued: "We
should not, and we will not, leave any stone unturned, even if this
means including the views of the so-called 'dissidents'."
Zuma said that an international panel being set up by the South African
government to advise on an appropriate national policy on AIDS included
"all points of view in the debate and is constituted of the most eminent
world scientists who can help to ensure that we understand HIV/AIDS
correctly and therefore respond to it correctly".
But the decision to set up the panel, and the way it is being done, has
itself come under criticism. Although the panel is due to meet for the
first time in South Africa next week, its members have not yet been
announced. Two medical researchers, both linked to the dissident
movement, are the only people who have confirmed their participation.
One is Gordon Stewart, professor emeritus of public health at the
University of Glasgow, who became well known in the 1970s for his
opposition to whooping-cough vaccine. The other is Sam Mhlongo,
professor of family health at the Medical University of South Africa,
north of Pretoria.
In 1997, Stewart co-authored an article with Eleni Papadopulos-Eleopulos
of the Royal Perth Hospital, Australia, and other 'dissidents' in the
journal Current Medical Research and Opinion. A later article in the
same journal by Papadopulos-Eleopulos and others on the pharmacology of
AZT, which claimed that the drug was unacceptably toxic, appeared to be
a major influence in Mbeki's refusal to sanction state provision of this
drug to prevent mother-to-child transmission of HIV (see Nature 402, 3;
During the debate in parliament last week, Mike Ellis, a member of the
Democratic Party, said that Mbeki seemed so defensive about AIDS that he
was placing sound judgement and rational thinking at risk. Kobus Gous,
health spokesman for the New National Party, accused the president,
through his contact with the dissidents, of having "given a podium to
discredited scientists, false hope to AIDS sufferers and created doubt
in the public mind".
But support for Mbeki's stance came from an unusual quarter when the
right-wing Boerestaat Party applauded the president's efforts to
"investigate the biggest hoax in the twentieth century".